My colleague Anthony Townsend recently posted about the eBay-Skype transaction,
Perhaps Ebay has a little more foresight and realizes that a little more intimacy in the transaction is what helps deals get done. I'm struggling with the broader implications - is this just another incremental improvement to Ebay or a sea change in the way we will trade online - through rich, multimedia, personal connections rather than anonymous bits of text and ratings?
If I read it rightly, he imagines-- and indeed, eBay itself is talking about-- a marriage of eBay and Skype, with the latter layered atop the former. A couple thoughts.
First, ratings aren't anonymous, and the paucity of bits may be a good thing in the current system.
Theoretically, at least, those doing the reviewing have identities and are real people (though one can game the system, just as one can game transactions in the real world). Indeed, one can argue that they've succeeded precisely because they're an example of what Malcolm Gladwell calls "thin-slicing": they only provide information on a participant's performance, and nothing else. The smooth salesman's tricks or the liar's honeyed words don't work on eBay; nor do prejudices get in the way of completing transactions or evaluating performance.
The question, it seems to me, is whether the addition of more layers of information-- and in particular, the addition of a VOIP service atop auctions, will either add to the volume/velocity of transactions, or correct whatever flaws or shortcomings exist in the current system.
I suspect that for some of us, part of the pleasure of eBay is knowing that we don't have to interact with salesmen the way we do in stores, but can still know enough to have a sense of whether we're going to get ripped off or not. Whether you can add more channels atop this system and have it still operate in the same way remains to be seen; and I think I'm skeptical that it can.
But maybe for really expensive purchases, or for things that require some hand-holding to learn to operate properly, being able to reach out and touch someone would be good. Maybe you really do need more bandwidth to make transactions above a certain size function. However, for small sellers of cheap goods, will Skype be a virtue or a curse? For people selling relatively inexpensive things that buyers can be a little nuts over-- Beanie Babies, say-- I'd imagine that it could be more trouble than it's worth.
Technorati Tags: business, internet
Recent Comments