Tom Foremski complains (following up on an earlier piece) about how the Valley has ignored Doug Engelbart-- and unintentionally demonstrates what he's complaining about.
Silicon Valley lauds this person and his work and his influence, and ignores him for more than 20 years? I cannot understand this attitude. Why isn't Doug sitting at Stanford University, guest lecturing from time to time?
The thing is, Doug actually does guest lecture at Stanford from time to time. (He did a course in 2000.) And Stanford and Institute for the Future (ahem) co-sponsored a day-long symposium on Doug's "Unfinished Revolution" in 1998-- almost six years ago. There were a flurry of tributes to him a couple years ago, and a more informal set now, thanks to the John Markoff book.
Still, while Doug's accomplishments are formidable, it now seems okay in the official culture of Silicon Valley to Forget Doug Engelbart. Our collective attention fixes on him briefly, but it's hard to stay focused; and eventually, we all seem to forget about him. Until the next round of tributes, and the next set of complaints about the lack of recognition.
In a forthcoming essay, I say that Doug is the Roy Orbison of Silicon Valley-- innovative early in his career, then forgotten for a long time, and honored in his old age. Foremski's post suggests that that's not quite true. Doug is more like Death in the Terry Pratchett novels: a character who's indispensable, who keeps showing up, but who ordinary humans can't quite recognize, and can't quite remember. People see Death, but their brains just can't handle processing the signal that says, "I see Death;" so through the miracle of neural plasticity, the brain translates him into Santa Claus, or nothing at all.
This is absolutely not to say that Doug doesn't deserve all the credit he now gets, and that in a fairer world he wouldn't get even more; it's an attempt to identify a weird blind spot in the Valley's collective consciousness. It seems absolutely determined to honor Doug, and at the same time ignore him.
Technorati Tags: Silicon_Valley, What the Dormouse Said
Recent Comments